A rusty book: a look at urban renaissance that lacks context

Beyond Rust tells the story of Pittsburgh's resurrection, but too often fails to look beyond the surface to explain why initiatives succeeded

emergency gibberishTORONTO, Ont. Feb. 15, 2017 /Troy Media/ – I judged a book by its cover recently – Beyond Rust seemed like it would be a good read. I’d learn more about Pittsburgh and the phenomenon known as the rust belt, and how some rusty areas came back.

The Pittsburgh Renaissance was aided by the Allegheny Conference on Community Development and public private partnerships, we’re told. Through these efforts, thousands of acres of strip and otherwise mined land became parks. New roads allowed more mobility and the modernization of tourist areas.

The author, Allen Dieterich-Ward, is an historian who has documented the facts well. But facts need defining, ordering and context.

Is the Pittsburgh Renaissance just a name for the comeback of a great city? Or is it a duly constituted organization with articles of association, letters patent or incorporation?

The Allegheny Conference seems to be a body, but its membership and its mission are not discussed in any detail.

As for public-private partnerships, this may mean nothing – as in the current ubiquitous use of “our partners” in government or “we’ll partner up with … .” Or it may mean some spot on the continuum of design, build, finance, maintain.

Beyond Rust often feels like one of those history books or local access TV documentaries on a small city. You have to know who and what is being talked about to understand why it’s important.

But there are some nuggets. We get the local perspective on the “coal wars,” a time of industrial strife that caused more deaths in America than modern terrorism. There are snippets on the fight for industrial safety, and the use of new technology and mining techniques to generate prosperity but reduce jobs. Industrialist Andrew Carnegie’s steel works and mergers, and the emergence of U.S. Steel, are covered. So too is the region’s contribution to the war effort.

The author tells us that during the day, people sometimes had to drive with headlights on and windshield wipers wiping because of industrial smoke. Some smoky days killed people – reminiscent of the old Soviet Bloc. Not surprisingly, it was in Pittsburgh that fights for clean air first took hold.

This book deals with more than just a few important subjects. One is the notion of ‘roads to jobs,’ which is still applied to transport in cities. Road improvement in Pittsburgh was supposed to connect areas of high unemployment with expanding suburbs. Another key subject is the value of sports stadia. A third is the gigantic shopping centre – often called The Golden Mile or Miracle Mile. And then there’s that great clean industry: tourism.

There are a few cautionary tales in these themes, which run through urban planning literature. First, the Cambridge/Boston area high-technology companies may be as much a function of being near several great universities as the quality of the paving. If pavement were the key to riches, New Brunswick would be wealthy as a result of more kilometres of pavement per capita than most jurisdictions. As for sports stadia, they do seem to make money for team owners through the rental of boxes, parking, concession sales and such. But what the average citizen gets out of the deal has not been studied well. And these days, shopping centres are being repurposed as office space or accommodation – or just abandoned.

There are only so many discretionary dollars to go around. You may get some payback, but you won’t create much new money with any of these initiatives.

One of the tourism ventures covered in the book was the restoration of Ohiopyle House, a 37-room hotel. Just after opening, arson destroyed it – “mountain justice,” said many locals who didn’t like change, being forced to move, sell their homes or otherwise didn’t see the wisdom in developers’ and planners’ efforts.

We’re not entirely beyond rust.

Troy Media columnist Dr. Allan Bonner has consulted on some of the major planning and public policy issues of our time on five continents over 25 years. He is the author of Safer Cities. Allan is included in Troy Media’s Unlimited Access subscription plan.

Looking for content for your publication or website?
Become a Troy Media subscriber.


The views, opinions and positions expressed by all Troy Media columnists and contributors are the author’s alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of Troy Media.

Submit a letter to the editor

Troy Media Marketplace © 2016 – All Rights Reserved
Trusted editorial content provider to media outlets across Canada

Please follow and like us: